Criticism Of Vroom%27s Expectancy Theory Of Motivation



Criticism of Vroom’s Expectancy theory 1) Edward Lawler claims that the simplicity of expectancy theory is deceptive because it assumes that if an employer makes a reward, employees will increase productivity to obtain the reward. However, this is only possible when if the employee thinks that it is beneficial to their immediate needs.

  • Expectancy Theory of Motivation was developed by Victor H. Vroom in 1964 and extended by Porter and Lawler in 1968. The theory is based on the assumption that our behavior is based on making a conscious choice from a set of possible alternative behaviors.
  • Still, the core of this theory depends on the cognitive process of how an individual analyses and processes motivational elements. Expectancy theory of motivation was first developed by Victor Vroom of the Yale School of Management.
  • Thus, Vroom’s Expectancy Theory has its roots in the cognitive concept, i.e. How an individual processes the different elements of motivation. This theory is built around the concept of valence, instrumentality, and Expectancy and, therefore, is often called as VIE theory. The algebraic representation of Vroom’s Expectancy theory is.
  • Vroom's expectancy theory of motivation concerns the process of individuals choosing one way to behave over another. It says that if people think that putting in effort leads to good performance and that good performance brings desirable rewards that satisfy one or more of their important needs, then they will be motivated to make the effort.

Vroom's Expectancy Theory of Employee Motivation - Quiz

Choose your answer and write the correct one down. Then click HERE for the answers to this quiz. Nelson intra 2100 manual.

NOTE: The transcript from the video is listed below the quiz for your reference. Cmecde sketchy medical videos 2017 microbiology pharmacology.

1. This person developed expectancy theory

  1. Victor Vroom
  2. Clayton Alderfer
  3. E.L. Thorndike
  4. Abraham Maslow
  5. David McCelland

2. Expectancy theory is based on these three components

  1. effort, performance, reward
  2. expectancy, performance, reward
  3. expectancy, performance, result
  4. effort, praise, return
  5. expectancy, praise, return

3. An employee who has a high level of expectancy for a valuable reward, also tends to have the motivation to increase performance.

  1. TRUE
  2. FALSE

4. The _________ has to be something the employee finds value in, making the efforts worth the perceived worth of the __________.

  1. expectancy
  2. performance
  3. result
  4. effort
  5. praise

5. This refers to the level of effort an employee is willing to exert in hopes that the increased effort will result in better performance.

  1. expectancy
  2. performance
  3. result
  4. effort
  5. praise

6. The level of this component is based on the strength of the relationship between an employee's behaviors and the rewards they can receive from those actions.

Vroom Expectancy Model

  1. expectancy
  2. performance
  3. result
  4. effort
  5. praise

Finding the right equation for motivating employees can be challenging. This lesson explains how expectancy theory is used to motivate employees by increasing the motivation to act based on a set of specific criteria.

Bob Buttkiss

Bob Buttkiss works at a local home improvement store. He's what some might consider a model employee. Bob is always the first one there and the last one to leave. While at work, he puts forth an effort that goes above and beyond his manager's expectations. He is always willing to take on extra projects as well as help his fellow coworkers with their jobs. Bob does not mind working the shifts that everyone else hates, and he does it with a smile. Some of Bob's coworkers think he's just plain crazy to work so hard at a job that pays so little, and others think he's a brown-noser, just trying to make himself look good to the manager.
Bob works at a local home improvement store.
However, for Bob, his efforts are not in vain. Rather, they are motivating for him. In fact, Bob believes strongly in the motto 'you get out what you put in,' and he expects that his efforts will eventually be recognized and rewarded by his manager. Because Bob dreams of becoming a manager himself one day, he is willing to do whatever it takes to work towards that goal.

Expectancy Theory

One of the most widely accepted theories of employee motivation was developed by Victor Vroom in 1964. Expectancy theory is based on the premise that a person will be motivated to put forth a higher level of effort if they believe their efforts will result in higher performance and thus better rewards. If we break down this definition, we can see three key components, which include expectancy, performance and reward.

Expectancy refers to the level of effort that an employee is willing to exert in hopes that the increased effort will result in better performance. For an employee whose review is based on how well they perform their jobs (which most job assessments are), the expectation is that the employee who works harder, such as Bob Buttkiss did in the previous example, can expect to reach a higher level of performance.
The reward has to be something the employee finds value in.
VroomAn employee is willing to work towards this higher level of performance because of the perceived correlation between performance and rewards. That is, that the level of performance is based on the strength of the relationship between an employee's behaviors and the rewards that they can receive from those actions. If working five extra hours a week will result in an eventual promotion, the willingness to work those extra hours increases due to the employee's desire to be awarded the promotion.

Finally, an assessment must also be made as to how valuable the employee finds the rewards to be. The reward therefore has to be something the employee finds value in, making the efforts worth the perceived worth of the reward. For many employees, the prospect of a promotion is a reward that is highly valuable and worth all of the effort that one would need to make in order to earn it. This is certainly true for our friend Bob Buttkiss.

Making Sense of the Equation

While the theory is not all-inclusive of all individual employee motivational needs, expectancy theory can help managers create motivational programs in the workplace. The key to understanding the process behind expectancy theory is determining the relationship between the effort and performance, between performance and reward and between rewards and employee satisfaction. An employee who has a high level of expectancy for a valuable reward also tends to have the high motivation to increase performance. For managers to take advantage of expectancy theory, they must show their employees the connection between their efforts and expectations of performance, then further demonstrate how meeting or exceeding those performance expectations will result in rewards the employee will find desirable.
For Bob, the prospect of a promotion is a valuable reward.
If we go back to the example of Bob Buttkiss and pretend to be his manager, you can use expectancy theory to continue to motivate him to work at a high level. As Bob's manager, one would first need to find out what rewards motivate Bob to work harder. If you recall, Bob was hoping for a promotion one day. As Bob's manager, you would want to be sure that that reward is something that can be offered to Bob. Once confirmed, you can meet with Bob to discuss your performance expectations with him and what he needs to do to reach his reward of a promotion. You will also want to confirm with Bob that he finds the reward valuable. By aligning performance expectations with rewards, Bob can quickly see what actions he needs to take to meet or exceed those expectations with the anticipation of being promoted some day. Bob's desire to satisfy the need to be promoted is strong enough to make the effort worthwhile, thus he is motivated to perform at high levels.

What Is Vroom's Expectancy Theory


Expectancy theory can motivate Bob to work at a high level.

Lesson Summary

Let's review. One of the most widely accepted theories of motivation was developed by Victor Vroom in 1964. It's known as expectancy theory, which is based on the premise that a person will be motivated to put forth a higher level of effort if they believe their efforts will result in higher performance and thus better rewards.

Expectancy theory is broken down into three components: expectancy, performance and reward. Expectancy refers to the level of effort an employee is willing to exert in hopes that the increased effort will result in better performance. The level of performance is based on the strength of the relationship between an employee's behaviors and the rewards that they receive from those actions. Finally, an assessment must also be made as to how valuable the employee finds the rewards to be. The reward therefore has to be something the employee finds value in, making the efforts worth the perceived worth of the reward.

While the theory is not all-inclusive of all individual employee motivational needs, expectancy theory can help managers to create motivational programs in the workplace. The key to understanding the process behind expectancy theory is determining the relationship between effort and performance, between performance and reward and between rewards and employee satisfaction. An employee who has a high level of expectancy for a valuable reward also tends to have a high level of motivation to increase performance.